Someone gives your ministry $100 online. A few days later, around $97 lands in your account. The missing few dollars went to donation processing fees, the cost your payment provider charges to move the money.
It is a small number per gift and a large one by December. As year-end giving picks up, more churches and faith-based nonprofits are asking the same question: should we let donors cover that fee for us? It is a fair question, and the answer is less about software than about how you want to treat the people who give.
Where the fee comes from
Any time a card moves money online, someone takes a cut. For most giving platforms the charge runs somewhere around two to three percent of the gift plus a small flat amount per transaction. That is true whether you use a church giving tool, a general donation platform, or a form built into your own website.
The fee is not a scam, and it is not optional in the way people sometimes hope. It pays for the card networks, the fraud protection, and the plumbing that lets a gift clear in seconds. The real choice is not whether the fee exists. It is who absorbs it: your ministry, or the donor who offers to.
The case for letting donors cover it
Most giving platforms now include a small checkbox on the form. Something like, "Add 3% so my full gift goes to the ministry." When a donor checks it, their $100 becomes roughly $103, and the full $100 reaches you.
Two things are worth knowing here. First, when the option is offered, a meaningful share of donors take it. People generally want their whole gift to count, and many are glad to close the gap once they understand it exists. Second, it protects your budget. For a small nonprofit, the fees on a strong December can add up to real money, money you would rather spend on the mission than on transaction costs.
For a lot of ministries, this is simply good stewardship made visible. You are being honest about a cost that used to stay hidden, and you are giving generous people a way to be a little more generous.
The case for quietly absorbing it
Some ministries make the opposite choice on purpose. They treat the fee as a normal cost of doing business, the same way they treat the electric bill, and they never ask the donor to think about it.
The reasoning is pastoral. Giving is already a tender moment, and every extra line on the form is one more thing between a person and the decision they came to make. A donor who feels nickel-and-dimed at the last second may give less, or hesitate, or close the tab. For some congregations, the goodwill of a frictionless gift is worth more than the few points you recover.
There is no wrong answer between these two. A healthy ministry can land in either place, as long as the choice is deliberate rather than an accident of whatever the platform shipped by default.
If you offer it, offer it honestly
The trouble starts when fee coverage stops being a clear choice and starts feeling like a trick. A few principles keep it clean.
Keep the language plain and warm. "Cover the processing fee so 100% of my gift supports the ministry" tells people exactly what they are doing and why. Skip anything that leans on guilt.
Be careful with defaults. Pre-checking the box so donors have to notice and uncheck it may lift your numbers, but it can cost you something harder to rebuild: trust. We lean toward leaving it unchecked and letting the donor opt in. A gift given freely is the whole point.
Make it easy to skip. The donor who cannot add the fee this month should feel just as welcome as the one who can. Their gift is not worth less, and the form should never imply it is.
A quiet test of how you steward things
However you decide, the fee is one of those small details that tells donors more than you might expect. A form that explains the cost in a sentence, offers a genuine choice, and never pressures anyone shows people that you handle money with care. That impression carries straight over to the bigger things they are trusting you with.
So it is worth an honest look before the December rush, rather than a setting someone toggled on setup day and forgot. Open your own giving form the way a first-time donor would, and read it slowly. Does the fee question feel like an invitation, or a catch?
If you would like a second set of eyes on your giving form before year-end, from the fee wording to the whole flow, we would be glad to walk through it with you. Reach us at developwithfaith.com/contact.

