It happens every year about this time. A family pulls up to the shelter with a trunk full of donations: three bags of summer clothes, a box of hotel shampoo, a microwave with a frayed cord, and one pack of the diapers you've been out of since October. They mean every bit of it. Your volunteers spend the afternoon sorting, and most of it goes straight to the thrift store or the dumpster.
Nobody did anything wrong. The family just didn't know what you needed, and the one place they looked, your website, didn't tell them.
From Thanksgiving through Christmas, faith-based nonprofits get more in-kind generosity than at any other time of year. Church groups run drives. Businesses collect boxes in the break room. Kids pick out toys. A clear, current needs list page is one of the simplest ways to point all of that goodwill at the people you serve.
Why a generic "donate items" page falls short
Most nonprofit sites we see have something like this: "We gratefully accept donations of food, clothing, and household items. Drop-offs are welcome during business hours."
That sentence is true, but it isn't much use. It sends people into their closets instead of into a store. It doesn't say which items run short, which ones you can't take, or which hours count as "business hours" during a holiday week when your schedule changes.
A needs list does three things the generic page can't:
- It directs generosity. People want to give something useful. If you name the item, they'll usually buy it.
- It protects your volunteers. Every unusable donation costs someone time to sort, store, or haul away, and in December you have very little time to spare.
- It honors the people you serve. A new winter coat in the right size says something different than a worn one that happened to be in the garage. Dignity starts with what's on the shelf.
What belongs on the page
Keep the page focused. One page, one job: tell people what to bring, how to bring it, and what to do instead if they'd rather not shop.
1. A "most needed right now" list at the top
Put your five to eight most urgent items first, and be specific. "Hygiene items" is vague. "Full-size deodorant, toothpaste, and razors" is something a person can find in a store aisle. If sizes matter, say so: "Men's winter coats, sizes L–XXL" or "Diapers, sizes 4–6."
Add a short line under the heading that shows when the list was last updated: "Updated November 21." That one line tells visitors the list is real and current, and it keeps your team honest about checking it.
2. A longer "always welcome" list
Below the urgent items, add a second list of things you'll accept any time of year. This is where canned protein, socks, and gift cards to the grocery store can live. Group it by category so it's easy to scan on a phone, because many people will pull up your page while they're standing in a store.
3. A short, gentle "please don't bring" list
This is the part most organizations leave out because it feels ungrateful. It isn't. A kind, clear "we can't accept" list prevents the awkward moment at the door when a volunteer has to turn someone away.
Phrase it with care: "To keep our guests safe and our space usable, we're not able to accept opened food, car seats, mattresses, or used undergarments. Thank you for understanding." If there's a better place for those items, link to it. Pointing someone to the right place is still a way of helping them give.
4. Drop-off details for the holidays
Give the address, the door to use, and the exact drop-off hours, including holiday closures. If you're closed on Thanksgiving Day and December 24–25, say so plainly on this page, not just on a sign on the door. A photo of the entrance helps first-time visitors find it.
If you take large deliveries from church or business drives, add a line asking groups to call or email ahead so you can have volunteers ready.
5. A "shop our list online" option
Some donors would rather order than drive. An online wish list through a major retailer lets them ship items straight to you. If you set one up, make sure the shipping address is one that can take deliveries during the holidays. Keep the online list in sync with your "most needed" items, because an outdated online list is just a slower way to get the wrong things.
6. A clear path to give money instead
Some people will read your list and realize that a gift of money is easier for them. Make that easy too. A single line near the bottom, "Prefer to give financially? A gift of $25 helps us buy exactly what's running low," with a link to your donation page, gives them a quick way to do that.
Don't treat this as a bait-and-switch. In-kind gifts and money both have a place. The point is to let each donor give in the way that suits them.
Make it a page people can share
Your needs list won't just be visited, it'll be forwarded. A small group leader will paste the link into a group text. A teacher will put it in a classroom newsletter. A youth pastor will put it on a slide.
A few small choices help it travel well:
- Use a short, permanent URL like
/needsor/donate-items, and keep it the same every year. Update the content, not the address. - Write a clear page title and description so the link preview looks right when it's shared in a text or on social media.
- Make the list printable. Many church drives still run on a sheet of paper taped to a collection box. A clean print view, or a simple downloadable one-page PDF, means your list is the one on the box.
Keep it current without adding a burden
The biggest risk with a needs list is that nobody updates it. The fix is a routine, not a new system.
Pick one person who walks the storage room weekly, ideally the volunteer or staff member who already knows what's running low. Give them a fifteen-minute slot on Monday mornings to update the "most needed" list and the date. If your website is hard to edit, that's a website problem worth solving, because the people closest to the shelves should be able to change this page without calling anyone.
When the season ends, don't take the page down. Shift it to your January needs. The shelves that overflowed in December are often bare by February, and the people who gave in the holidays are glad to hear where they can help next.
Generosity deserves good directions
There's an old picture in Scripture of people bringing so much to build the tabernacle that the craftsmen finally had to say, enough. Most of us will never have that problem. But we can make sure that what people bring in faith actually reaches the people it was meant for.
A needs list page is a small thing. It's one page and a weekly habit. It also shows the families, churches, and neighbors who want to help that you've thought ahead for them.
If you'd like help building a needs list page, or making your current one easier for your team to update, get in touch with us. We'd be glad to help you get it live while the holiday drives are still in full swing.

